| Live
Whacking Permalink Archive
click
"Live Whacking" button for the latest entries
13
September 2004
In
case you were wondering
I've
been ill.
I'm
better now.
link
Quote
of the day
I
am no enthusiast for the democratic process, which I just regard as
little more than a system of legitimising proxy mugging. I can see a
role for democracy as a countervailing force even in a limited-government
minarchist state, but as currently practiced it is rarely more than
just a way to try and appropriate the money of others, impose restriction
on competitors and generally add the force of law to personal prejudices
in ways that conflate state and society to the profound determent of
the later.
-
Perry de Havilland, Samizdata
link
The
World According to George Monbiot
While
in the midst of my last virus-induced vomiting fit, I had time to peruse
George Monbiot's website. It's not
an activity I'd recommend to healthy people.
Reading
his collected thoughts reminded me of the final scene in one of the Pink
Panther movies, where Herbert Lom's character - driven mad by his
hatred of Clouseau - lies straightjacketed in a padded room, writing messages
on the walls with a crayon between his toes.
Monbiot's
mental powers may be on par with Inspector Dreyfuss, yet in today's
world, Monbiot gets employed by broadsheets like The Guardian, saving
the taxpayer
the cost of keeping him medicated.
Monbiot's
worldview is an upchucked hodgepodge of dreary Marxist prophecy, Luddite
pre-industrial fantasy, sub-Chomsky politics and ecological paranoia.
Yet
what sets Ol' Moonbat apart from his hate-the-world ideological comrades,
is just how much he seems to enjoy wallowing in his own misery. While
raving batheads like the ISO, radical Islamists and the Greenies are at
least marching towards some nutty new dawn, George seems to spend most
of his time saying we're fucked, and we deserve it. All that's left
is to strip off our clothes and go hump fruit in the forest.
There
are three obsessions which seem to feed everything George writes:
1a-
Modern society is destroying the environment.
1b- No-one, especially not capitalists, must be allowed to use
market mechanisms or new technologies to limit environmental damage.
2a-
We are running out of food so everyone will starve to death.
2b- No-one, especially not capitalists, must be allowed to increase
food production to feed the hungry.
3a-
the capitalist system exploits the third world and keeps it poor.
3b- No-one, especially not capitalists, must be allowed to globalise
their businesses and give opportunities to the third world.
That
pretty much covers everything he writes. Let's look at some specifics.
Take
George on energy:
The
oil industry tells us not to worry: the market will find a way of sorting
this out. If the price of energy rises, new sources will come onstream.
But new sources of what? Every other option is much more expensive than
the cheap oil which made our economic complexity possible.
Gosh.
Sounds like the end, don't it? I guess people with brains could point
out several hundred examples of new products getting cheaper as a new
market develops, though this seems a little beyond Monbiot. Or more likely,
solutions scare Monbiot, as they tend to play havoc with his apocalypse
fantasies.
Think
I'm being mean? Have a gander at his sociopathic ideas on environmental
aesthetics:
Like
other lifeforms, we exist only to replicate ourselves. We have become
so complex only because that enables us to steal more energy. One day,
natural selection will shake us off the planet. Our works won’t
even be forgotten. There will be nothing capable of remembering.
[...]
It
seems to me that the only higher purpose we could possibly possess is
to seek to relieve suffering: our own and that of other people and other
animals. This is surely sufficient cause for any project we might attempt.
It is sufficient cause for the protection of fine art or rare books.
It is sufficient cause for the protection of rare wildlife.
Biodiversity,
in other words, matters because it matters. If we are to protect wildlife,
we must do it for ourselves. We need not pretend that anything else
is bidding us to do so. We need not pretend that anyone depends upon
the king protea or the golden toad or the silky sifaka for their survival.
But we can say that, as far as we are concerned, the world would be
a poorer place without them.
Not surprisingly,
Monbiot - horrified by the prospect of despoiling ecological aesthetics
- has no problems with bludgeoning us all into becoming good, green, global
citizens. He wants to ban private
motor vehicles, air
travel, stop the evils of advertising
and tax corporations till they choke. We can't help the poor to grow GM
crops to feed themselves, because GM food is, um, evil
or capitalistic
or something.
Oh, and have I mentioned
his...erm....interesting ideas about economics?
Capitalism is
not even mathematically possible, let alone biologically viable
Yes, that's a real
quote. It comes from this
essay:
We are going
backwards. The reason should not be hard to grasp. Our economic system
depends upon never-ending growth, yet we live in a world with finite
resources. Our expectation of progress is, as a result, a delusion.
He might be on to
something here. Well, except from all the actual progress which has taken
place I guess.
Capitalism is
a millenarian cult, raised to the status of a world religion. Like communism,
it is built upon the myth of endless exploitation. Just as Christians
imagine that their God will deliver them from death, capitalists believe
that theirs will deliver them from finity. The world’s resources,
they assert, have been granted eternal life.
It's kind of like
saying that your average doctor believes in immortality.
It is possible
to change the way we live. The economist Bernard Lietaer has shown how
a system based upon negative rates of interest would ensure that we
accord greater economic value to future resources than to present ones.
By shifting taxation from employment to environmental destruction, governments
could tax over-consumption out of existence.
Uh, what?
Oh wait, here's the
money quote:
Overturning
this calculation is the greatest challenge humanity has ever faced.
We need to reverse not only the fundamental presumptions of political
and economic life, but also the polarity of our moral compass. Everything
we thought was good—giving more exciting presents to our children,
flying to a friend’s wedding, even buying newspapers—turns
out also to be bad.
Lovely bloke. Providing
for your children, consuming for enjoyment and travelling to see friends
is evil, but dismantling modern society for the sake of ecological
aesthetics is the new moral imperitive.
Not surprisingly,
Monbiot drops his moral objections where it suits him. He flies the Evil
Skies to give international lectures. He travels by car when he needs
to. Global corporations and the mental pollution of advertising are A-OK
when they help to sell his books. And the bloke seems rather keen to appear
on the idiot box at every opportunity.
Monbiot builds his
ideological comforts on the lives of others, discards his ideals when
they prove incovenient, then has the nerve the lecture the rest of us
on responsible citizenship.
I've finally worked
out what I'm reading: this is Mein Kampf on acid.
link
"Suicide-bombers
are evil, but...."
The
Green Left Weekly gives us their view
on the Jakarta bombing:
Such
acts are inhumane, stupid and futile. But they are also a symptom of
a world where poverty, desperation and hopelessness about the future,
and humiliation of culture, religion, race and nation are more and more
pronounced. These evils are driving some people to acts of insane cruelty.
Those
who can most be held responsible for this situation are the people in
power: those who decide things; who design how the world works; who
declare wars, invade countries, support foreign occupations and blithely
continue policies wreaking economic terror on the billions of people
who live in the Third World.
Natually,
when Islamic lunatics conduct their slaughter, the Israelis aren't without
blame....
The
Australian government should also end its support for the barbaric and
cruel occupation by Israel of Palestine. It must immediately announce
an end to its shameful support for the Israeli wall of terror.
And
while we're on the subject on Israel and the Green Left Weekly,
check out terrorist-loving hag Rihab Charida's report
from Ramallah.
Oh,
and as for the Beslan massacre, you'll
never guess where the Green Left's sympathies lie.
link
Another
car I want
I
gots me a hankering for a Holden
HSV Maloo ute

Firebreathing
performance, great looks, nice interior, and I can stick my bikes in the
back.
link
Christ,
not again
Crazy Joe Vialls'
reaction to the Beslan massacre and the Jakarta bombing: psychological
warfare and mini-nukes launched by the Zionist cabal in New York.
No, really. It's amazing
these Zionist plotters ever have time to go to the toilet.
link
|